New Idea? Abolish Politics at Parish Level
By thurti365 | Sunday, February 17, 2013, 11:13
Having viewed some very worrying documentation and knowing that some very committed local residents, who do not have a political bone in their bodies, have only the town's interest at heart rather than the agenda of a political party, can we not try to remove the town council completely? In other words, rather like the wonderful group that organises Portishead Christmas Lights (as just one example), this town should have committees only with the one proviso that no resident can sit on such a committee if they are a member or contributor to a recognised political party. This idea was suggested at the weekend by a local resident to a group standing around her in the High Street. All were in favour.
-
Folk Hall
Then the contentious air currently hanging over Portishead will evaporate. There will be no need for politics because decisions will be made by Portishead interest groups only and money allocated to them from Portishead funds managed by Portishead residents. The need to go crawling cap in hand to Portishead Town Councillors will cease.
Projects like the free for all, open air skatepark would have been managed and undoubtedly resolved with ease, after one consultation with the public (rather than consultation being overridden) and whatever the outcome, Portishead would have to accept it graciously.
What has encouraged me to promote the above idea? Just read the following from the Lake Grounds Ward Councillor, written to the one Conservative councillor who voted in support of the skatepark on Wednesday evening (in other words against Cllr Walters' motion not to support it). The correspondence was written on the 7th September 2010 at 22.27 p.m. after a meeting of councillors and before the 2011 Elections. It speaks for itself but certainly does not speak for Portishead.
"With the 2011 elections fast approaching, we need to be singing off the same hymn sheet and at the moment it seems we are not on the subject of a skatepark in Portishead. Your NSC colleagues have made it clear - no skatepark on the Lakegrounds, yet by consulting with Cllr Stanley and her Lib Dem SP team we are clearly divided. I suggest we meet before the next 2011 meeting on the 20th to resolve what appears to be a serious issue".
The letter also includes the following:
"Even if the appeal overturns NSC's decision, landlord's permission is required and that is most unlikely under the current balance of power".
That one Conservative town councillor to whom this letter was written, bravely ignored the political pressure upon her and voted after seeing the facts, after reading public planning consultation and listening to her heart that was telling her to do right for her town. Incidentally, although the letter was written to her (and her husband!), it was copied to the other Conservative town councillors and strangely a district councillor Carl Francis Pester who has nothing to do with Portishead. Other names to which it was copied have been blanked out and not released as part of the Freedom of Information request.
How does one I wonder, propose removing poliics at local level because while I would never want to join the allegiance of councillors here, I would jump at the chance of being part of a non political committee that only has the town at heart, in a community where town politics would not exist in any shape or form.

Comments
I support this recommendation
By BeeWee at 20:20 on 27/02/13
ReportIs this the Jane and Crankie show?
I'd love to here other people's views on this most Important area of public policy
By CaryHarry at 21:41 on 25/02/13
Reportthurti365 I have to agree with everything you said that is how it should be but will it ever happen like you said too many people stuck in there ways
By johnstorm at 09:39 on 21/02/13
ReportJohn, I am aware already of what has happened in Frome which is an achievement but that is only part of the story. There are still party politics at foot in Frome and undoubtedly the minority parties with a seat there would do anything to once again have a majority although perhaps those councillors have rather more integrity than those I see here locally. I believe politics in any form is not conducive to community cohesion. From what I can see from political history in this town, I truly believe that party politics should not exist in any form within the parish of Portishead. If you allow Independents to stand against the main parties in an election, you are sanctioning the political process. I disagree with the political manipulation that occurs within that system at a local level. Remove the political system and you remove tactical voting as well as illegitimate campaigns full of broken promises, residents who would vote for anything as long as it is wearing the right colour rosette, politicians in Independents' sheeps clothing (as seen in Portishead) and the money game surrounding party politics.
Surely the fairest system of all has to be an entirely politics free community? Frome had the right intentions but hasn't got it right. They could of course go a step closer to the ideal and request a referendum to remove the political system completely at parish level. The problem then would be, which of those Independents would want to be the figurehead?
The serious problem has always been in Portishead that people vote for a particular party because they have done for years and often they know nothing about the candidate. There has been so little choice of candidates in recent years that the Conservatives win by default because they have not been contested and despondent voters do not turn out. If politics was removed and the residents of Portishead had to vote for a town figurehead (or mayor), how refreshing would that be? Better than that pint of lager in Ice Cold in Alex!!
Even our local media would take on a new light without one constantly publicity seeking councillor feeding stories to a reporter who fails to check all the details are accurate. We would have an air of truth instead of the stench of suspicion. We would also never have a coalition that has proved so damaging in central government.
By thurti365 at 01:13 on 21/02/13
ReportJohn, I have followed your link, don't have time to read it all now but will certainly look at it later. It seems very like what is needed here.
By Hillcran at 10:08 on 20/02/13
ReportShow all Comments